I have put PSA on blast before due to their blatant disregard for obviously fake autos when grading cards. Because of their stupid policy of only grading the card, instead of the card AND the auto, its easy to slip fakes past this “authority” on autographs. This is probably one of the more comical examples of PSA just refusing to identify a card as altered when it is obviously signed with a different pen and a different signature.
Personally, this is what I think happened:
The card was packed pulled with an autograph, but the autograph was not well signed, as some of them are not. Rather than take a hit on the price, the autograph was removed with nail polish remover and resigned by the scammer. It was re-autographed by some scammer and submitted to PSA with a “card only grade.” It was then authenticated as a 10 because it is a real card.
The auto is as fake as ever.
I am not saying the seller of the card was the one responsible, but someone is.
NEVER trust PSA if you have any question about a card with a fake signature.