Your Guide To Grading and Autograph Authentication

There are two services within the industry that are enormous money makers for their respective parent companies. One of them is card grading, and the other is autograph authentication. In fact, they have become so ingrained within the hobby environment, that the rulings provided by some of the bigger companies are considered gospel by almost all casual collectors. They have been the center of recent controversy, but the stories only serve to showcase their place among us more than ever. If you receive an autograph and get it graded, that grade can increase or decrease the value significantly. If you get a an autograph certified, by all intents and purposes, its considered real.

I wont come on here and say that the process of grading and autograph authentication isnt a drawn out and controlled situation, but I dont think there are any reservations in saying that it isnt perfect. However, when you look at the landscape, there are some significant discrepancies in the trust people have in certain companies, and lack of trust in others. I dont always support the practice of using these companies, but that means little to the majority of the people out there. If you have questions, here is my guide.

Here is how I break it down for the companies that are, in my opinion, more reliable, as well as their perceived specialty:

BGS – Graded Modern Cards

When it comes to grading cards that were produced in the so called ‘modern’ era, BGS is the gold standard (pun intended). They have built a sterling reputation, despite my own reservations on the nature of their business. I would even go so far as saying that when it comes to grading cards, its hard to go the wrong direction in buying a BGS 9.5 and above, as their scrutiny of modern examples has built them a huge customer base. Their business of grading chrome cards from over the years is pretty remarkable, and its because there is so much trust in the grades they give. Yes, I realize I am giving a good review to Beckett on something, but I cant deny its place and relevance in the hobby. I still think that the value placed on the different iterations of the grading structure is fucking nuts, but it is what it is. For whatever reason, that microscopic and subjective difference in grades can mean thousands of dollars in value, but thats what happens.

PSA/DNA – Autograph Authentication / Vintage Graded Cards

In a lot of cases, I think the certifications of autographs is about as inexact a science as can be, at least when you get to professional forgeries like we saw with Operation Bullpen. That being said, PSA is about as solid a certification as you can get on an autograph, as their reputation (though not perfect) is one of the best. We all have good examples of why their auth procedure isnt what it should be, but no process can be as long as a human is making biased and subjective decisions. I say “biased” because humans naturally have bias, which is unavoidable, and in my opinion, I think that there is reason to believe that larger customers tend to have more success with their stuff.

As for the vintage card grading, PSA is king. They have an audience in a part of the hobby that is ever aging, but still growing. The people who comprise this market are usually quite liberal with spending, and arent afraid to drop major cash in getting their cards certified. Because so many of the high dollar vintage cards come with significant risk of fakes, certification is KEY to getting top dollar for your cards. Usually, a BGS 9.5 can outsell a PSA 10 in modern, but not so in vintage.

PSA also does a great job playing to the vanity of collectors with their set registry, something I find incredibly cool. It basically showcases which collector has the highest graded collection of a certain set according to a number of factors. Its great.

JSA – Autograph authentication

We all know that James Spence is thought of with high regard in his autograph authentications, and from what my understanding is, he got his start with PSA in the first place. Although his company doesnt seem to have the same kind confidence as PSA, their partnership with BGS to authenticate cards has proven to be a great business venture. For the normal types of auth, I would definitely feel comfortable with a JSA certificate. For the more difficult autographs, I would feel much more comfortable with PSA as a personal preference. Im talking Mantle, Ruth, etc.

SGC – Pre-war Card Grading and Authentication

If there is a type of card that I know little to nothing about, its pre-war cards that can come in all sorts of varieties. SGC has become the go to service for grading these cards, as their encyclopedic knowledge of the different brands allows for some incredibly accurate grading. Considering the different issues that pre-war cards have in the age and quality of stock, that is saying something.

Other autograph related auths – all good and reputable:

Tristar – these guys are a huge business and sponsor many of the signings around the country. Tri-Star certs are usually witnessed first hand and are completely legit.

Mounted Memories – again, see above. Its basically the same concept, and I would trust these guys too.

Upper Deck and Panini Authentic – I dont think I need to explain why these are good items, but you will pay through the nose to get them.

Steiner – again, high end retail certification focusing on New York, but completely reliable. Expect to pay big money over normal market price.

Here are companies that I have less confidence in:

GAI – Card grading and auto authentication

At one point, GAI was reasonably reliable in terms of their reputation around the hobby, but over the last five years that has all gone to shit with some of the problems their business has had. The rumor going around is that they were in the red for finances all around, and started offering relaxed standards to get more submissions. As a result, you have a lot of alleged forgeries and high grades getting certified without much thought. I would not buy a GAI auth’ed autograph, and I ESPECIALLY wouldnt buy a graded card. The cert carries no weight, and guarantees nothing to me.

NSA – Knick knack 1/1s

I have done a number of posts on NSA, mostly in regards to their fabrication of “game used” jersey cards created by them and encapsulated for sale on eBay. Based on the quality of the swatch and the youtube videos showcasing the quality of the cards, I think its obvious to me that there isnt much reliability in the cards they provide. I wouldnt trust them one single bit, but that doesnt stop people from buying them for the last few years. Its sickening to think they make money. Sucker born every minute.

BCCG – Graded cards

From my understanding, BCCG is an offshoot of BGS, but without the same standards in which they grade cards. In other words, a BCCG 10 means nothing close to a BGS 10 in any way shape or form. Its not that they are untrustworthy, just that the cards arent held with the same type of value.

Other Companies

There are literally a million companies that do grading and authentication, and it isnt worth the risk to buy them over an auth from a reliable company. I would stick to what you know, and these guys are so tiny that they have no accountable reputation to speak of. Because of how much money is involved with grading, these guys will try to capitalize at every turn. Dont even think twice, just avoid.

Again, this article is built off my personal opinions on the matter, and I am open to hearing what other people have to say. I have had a lot of questions on what to do with certain items, and hopefully this will shed some light on it.

10 thoughts on “Your Guide To Grading and Autograph Authentication

  1. I can only speak from my experience outside of using BGS and PSA…I sent 40 cards in to a company called GMA…Gem Mint Authentication. I just wanted to test it out for shits and giggles. I live in Florida and they are based about 2 hours from me so I figured the turn around time would make it worth a try. At 2 dollars per card, I figured what the hell. I sent in some middle of the road priced inserts…nothing worth more than 10 bucks. They should just call themselves what they are…Gem Mint 10 Authentication. Of the 40 cards I sent in, exactly 33 of them were graded Gem Mint 10. One of them was a Jordan Star Attractions Die-Cut card that had a hugely noticeable ding on one of the back corners. An 8 at best…yet it got a Gem Mint 10. I’d say that out of 40 cards, they overgraded 20 of them. Also when you submit something to GMA, they send you an informational form on how you yourself can become a GMA Grader. You pay them for the empty slabs and submit your cards with the grade YOU assign to them, and they slab them for you with YOUR grade on them. Shady as fuck. I can say with BGS and PSA, I’ve generally agreed with their grades…you truly get what you pay for.

  2. This article reminded me how awful NSA is. I still can’t believe they can get away with that.

  3. Nice list.

    I would add that you may be a little too harsh with GAI and their autograph authentication services. I will add that GAI grading is another story. I’ve heard too many horror stories about their card grading. When it comes to the autographs, I don’t believe they do any actual authenticating like PSA/DNA or JSA. In SoCal they were frequently used as onsite authentication services for autograph appearances. So, if it’s a SoCal local autograph signer it’s likely real.

  4. Hi i have a indy car matchbox size and i personally got it autographed by Danica Patrick and the whole pit and they also peeled off the qualifying sticker off her car that she just raced, my question is, who do you recommend me sending it to, to get it authenticated ??? Thank You Very Much, Pete…

  5. I have also used PSA and GMA. When PSA fucks you for a bad grade some how it feels worst since they cheat you for the costs of the slab and the bad grade.. And never mind that it takes for ever to get your stuff back. PSA and that JSA charge you for a opinion !! GMA is fast and does a very good job at being fair. Its only my opinion but I think PSA and JSA try to control the market by only letting a few 10 “s and only a certain amount of autographs hit the market. Tons of 9’s on cards that come straight out of the pack and into a holder. And who does’t think that the more business you do with that company the better grades you get.

  6. I just purchased an Aroldis Chapman Premier Prospects Rookie Art Card that was graded by GMA. I wish I had done some more research. Not only am I suspicious of the grading (slab seems sturdy though) I am now suspicious of the prominence. I always thought Premier Prospects was a subsidiary of Upper Deck.

    I looked at the card, and am now tempted to open it and reslab it without the grade, but what also bothers me is I see no markings to indicate that this was made by Upper Deck or Premier. Just a a painted canvas on cardstock. Any ideas?

  7. I have been doing with GMA for over 5 years. The haters should keep using PSA. I will stick to $2.50 a card and my cards back in 5 days. Some people have been brain washed into thinking its ok to pay $15-$20 to grade a card. Lets be serious.

    As for quality. Solid holder, cool label and excellent customer service. GMA gets an A+ from me.

  8. Say what you want but after reading several reviews that you “get alot of 10s from GMA” I thought Id give them a try with some low grade BGS and PSA I had( 4-7). 5 from each, broke them out of slab hoping to get a higher grade. All Psa came back same friggen grade. Only one of the BGS came back higher, but only .5 higher. Two came back with lower grades. Not sure who actually grades down there at GMA but they were spot on with the other two companies (or I was being set up)…either way, Ive started using them. Cheap and fast is a plus too

  9. GMA is a solid company with fast service. I use them for the bulk of my auction-house grading services.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *